SHAMEFUL Second Grade Lesson On What Thanksgiving REALLY Is

Grandfather carving a roast turkey at a family dinner table
Photo: LightField Studios / Shutterstock

Loudoun County Public Schools in Virginia recommends a lesson for children as young as second grade that calls Thanksgiving a “Day of Mourning,” and the district says it wants students to learn history “through multiple perspectives.”

Story Snapshot

  • A Loudoun County teachers’ guide for the 2026-27 school year recommends a Thanksgiving lesson for grades 2 through 5 that calls the holiday a “Day of Mourning” for some Native American groups.
  • The same guide lists Indigenous Peoples’ Day instead of Columbus Day and offers older students a lesson called “Columbus Day- A Debated Celebration.”
  • A watchdog group, Protect the Public’s Trust, got the guide through a public records request.
  • A district spokesman said the school system is “intentional about ensuring students have opportunities to learn about history through multiple perspectives.”

Guide Recommends Mourning Framework For Young Students

The records were first reported on Thursday, November 12. They show that Loudoun County Public Schools, in Northern Virginia, keeps a guide for teachers called “Resources for Recognition Days & Months.” Asked about the lessons, a district spokesman explained the reason behind them: the district is “intentional about ensuring students have opportunities to learn about history through multiple perspectives and to develop a more complete understanding of historical events.” The guide was first put together in 2024 and revised for the 2026-27 school year. It gives teachers outside lessons they can draw on for holidays and other special days. Protect the Public’s Trust, a group that watches how government agencies behave, got the guide through a public records request, which is a formal request for government documents.

For grades 2 through 5, the guide recommends a lesson called “The Real Story of Thanksgiving.” The district says it “focuses on the traditions as well as the Native American perspective.” One slide says: “Some Native American groups protest Thanksgiving as a Day of Mourning.” According to reports, the lesson also says the arrival of European explorers “is not a cause for celebration.” For middle and high school students, the guide adds a second lesson, “Thanksgiving: A Day of Mixed Blessings.”

The “Day of Mourning” idea is not new. Starting in 1970, a group called the United American Indians of New England began marking Thanksgiving Day as a National Day of Mourning, with a yearly gathering in Plymouth, Massachusetts. The difference here is that the idea sits in a district holiday guide for second graders.

Columbus Day Lesson Built Around Controversy

The guide’s October list uses Indigenous Peoples’ Day, not Columbus Day. For middle and high school students, it offers a lesson called “Columbus Day- A Debated Celebration.” The lesson asks students to “reflect on the controversy of this holiday and its impact on indigenous populations.”

The guide’s table of contents lists December, but the month is never mentioned again. The guide goes straight from Thanksgiving in November to Martin Luther King Jr. Day in January. Christmas does not appear at all.

Parents Push Back Against ‘Guilt’ In Classrooms

Alexa Moutevelis, the communications director for Protect the Public’s Trust, said the materials filter history through a “DEI lens.” DEI stands for diversity, equity and inclusion. She urged parents to pay close attention to what their children are taught. Critics also point to President Trump’s January 2025 executive order, “Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling,” and say the guide may run against it.

On Friday, November 13, Loudoun County parent Rachel Pisani went on Fox & Friends to criticize the lessons. Co-host Ainsley Earhardt agreed with her. “These are second graders. They’re teaching them to feel guilty about living in America,” Earhardt said. “This is a holiday for America. It’s about family. I’m not mourning on Thanksgiving.” She said schools should “tell them we’re grateful to live in the best country in the world, and we’re thankful.”

What The District Has Said

The district’s public response has been its spokesman’s statement about teaching history “through multiple perspectives” so students get “a more complete understanding of historical events.” The district has not said whether teachers must use these lessons. The guide calls them outside resources that teachers can draw on.

Thanksgiving break in Loudoun County runs Wednesday, November 25, through Friday, November 27. That gives parents a little over a week to ask their child’s teacher which holiday lessons will be used in class.

Sources:

freebeacon.com, thepostmillennial.com, lifezette.com, toddstarnes.com, foxnews.com, washingtonparent.com, shec.ashp.cuny.edu