
A top federal prosecutor warned Sen. Elizabeth Warren that her plan to investigate President Trump’s private associates could break federal civil rights laws.
Story Highlights
- U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz of the Southern District of Texas sent Warren a formal letter on Sunday, November 15, ordering her to preserve records tied to her planned investigations.
- The letter says Warren seems eager to wield her gavel “like a tomahawk,” words that reports say mock her past claims about her heritage.
- Reitz says Warren plans to use her coming Banking Committee gavel to target people close to Trump, which he says could punish them for their political ties.
- His letter cites two federal civil rights laws, 18 U.S.C. 241 and 242.
- Warren must confirm in writing by 6 p.m. Eastern on Monday, November 23, that the records are being kept.
- Warren has said her probes are aimed at “anyone who has been cheating” families and investors.
Prosecutor Puts Warren on Notice
On Sunday, November 15, U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz sent Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) a preservation notice. That is a formal demand that a person keep, and not destroy, records that could matter in a later legal fight. Reitz is the top federal prosecutor for the Southern District of Texas. His reason, he says, is that Warren appears ready to use congressional investigations to go after private citizens simply because they are close to President Trump. In a post about the letter, Reitz wrote, “Congressional investigations can’t be used to punish Americans for exercising their 1A rights.” The “1A” means the First Amendment, which protects free speech and the right to associate with whom you choose.
Warren’s office has not answered the letter in public, according to reports. In her own words, the investigations she has promised are about fraud, not politics. She has said they target people who have been “cheating American families and scamming your investors.” The White House sided with Reitz. Communications director Steven Cheung said Democrats like Warren are trying to “weaponize their positions” against people close to Trump.
What the Letter Demands
The letter orders Warren, her Senate staff, her consultants and her campaign workers to keep “all documents, communications, and other electronically stored information” tied to the planned probes. Reitz gave her until 6 p.m. Eastern on Monday, November 23, to confirm in writing that she got the notice and is keeping the records.
Reitz warned that failing to keep the records could bring “sanctions, adverse-inference instructions, or other penalties.” An adverse-inference instruction is when a judge tells a jury it may assume that missing records would have hurt the side that lost them. A preservation demand is not a subpoena or a court order, and it charges no one with a crime.
Reitz also used sharp words. He wrote that Warren seems “eager to wield your future gavel like a tomahawk, hunting for the scalps of President Trump’s private associates.” According to reports, the letter’s Native American references appear to mock Warren’s past claims about her heritage.
Warren’s TV Comments Set It Off
Reitz pointed to Warren’s November 8 interview on Face the Nation with host Margaret Brennan. Asked about her plans for the new Congress, Warren said lawmakers must pass laws and investigate. “We have to do both,” she said. “If you’ve been making your profits by cheating American families and scamming your investors, you better get ready for some investigations, serious ones.” Asked whom she meant, she answered, “Anyone who has been cheating.”
Reitz said the remarks send “a strong smoke signal” that Warren plans “to target private individuals close to President Trump.” He also cited a letter Warren sent with Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) and Rep. Robert Garcia (D-Calif.) about money raised for Trump projects such as the new White House ballroom.
The Laws Behind the Warning
Reitz built his warning on two federal criminal laws. Section 241 makes it a crime for two or more people to plot to threaten or scare someone out of using a constitutional right. Section 242 makes it a crime for anyone acting with government power to take away a person’s rights on purpose. Reitz wrote that Americans may associate freely without elected officials “terrorizing them with aggressive, harassing government action.”
Congress has long had the power to investigate so it can write laws, and the Supreme Court has upheld that power many times. The Court has also set limits. Because of the First Amendment, lawmakers may not dig into a person’s political ties at will with no link to a real need. Attorney General Todd Blanche has said there are “no ongoing investigations, criminal investigations, into words that incoming senators or congressmen have said.”
Warren Is Not the Only One
The letter to Warren is the third Reitz has sent to Senate Democrats in a matter of days. He sent similar warnings to Blumenthal and Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.) over their own public talk of investigating Trump allies. Blumenthal called the threat “baseless” and sent Reitz a preservation demand of his own. “As incoming Chair of the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, I will not be intimidated,” Blumenthal said.
The fight matters because of what comes in January. Warren is the top Democrat on the Senate Banking Committee and is set to become its chair when the new Congress meets. The committee oversees Wall Street and the big banks. Reitz’s letter arrived before she has even picked up the gavel, and her answer is due Monday, November 23.
Sources:
politico.com, newsweek.com, cbsnews.com, detroitnews.com, foxnews.com, thehill.com



