
The Supreme Court turned away President Trump’s bid to cancel about $59 million in University of California research grants, leaving in place a ruling that the cuts likely punished researchers for their views on diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI).
Story Snapshot
- The Supreme Court refused to hear the Trump administration’s appeal, with no justice noting a dissent and no explanation given.
- A federal appeals court had found the grant cuts likely violated the First Amendment because they targeted researchers’ viewpoints.
- Two agencies, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities, had canceled the grants under Trump’s orders against DEI programs.
- The administration argued it can stop paying for research that no longer fits its priorities.
What The Supreme Court Did And What Stands
On Monday, November 16, the Supreme Court declined to take up the case, known as Trump v. Thakur. The justices did not explain why, and none publicly disagreed. That leaves in place a ruling from the Ninth Circuit, the federal appeals court for California and other Western states. It found that the grant cuts likely broke the First Amendment, which bars the government from punishing people for the views they express.
The grants were cut because the agencies said the research no longer matched Trump’s priorities, including his opposition to DEI. In the first days of his second term in January 2025, Trump signed executive orders telling agencies to end grants tied to DEI and some other topics. About $59 million was left on the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants when they were canceled, according to the administration’s filing. Some of the grants run as late as November 2029.
Turning down a case is not a ruling on who is right under the Constitution, and it sets no new rule for the whole country. But it means the order to keep the money flowing to the researchers stays in effect while the case goes on.
How The Lower Courts Saw The Cuts
Six University of California researchers sued in June 2025 after termination letters began arriving that April. The lead plaintiff, Neeta Thakur, is an associate professor at the University of California, San Francisco. Their lawyers said the agencies searched grant files for words such as “diversity,” “climate change” and “gender ideology” and then canceled the awards that used them.
In June 2025, U.S. District Judge Rita Lin, a Biden appointee in Northern California, ordered the grants restored. She found the cuts were likely based on the viewpoint the research was seen to express. She also wrote that the researchers faced funding shortfalls, possible layoffs and harm to their careers.
On May 26, 2026, the Ninth Circuit agreed. It said the administration “has not merely exercised its power to choose the programs it funds.” Instead, the court found, it picked out single grants to end because of the recipients’ perceived views on DEI and environmental justice. The court did throw out a separate part of the order that covered grants ended by form letters with no specific reason.
What The Administration Argued
The Justice Department asked the Supreme Court to decide whether agencies may weigh the viewpoint of research when they hand out or end competitive grants. Its lawyers argued the government gets to decide which research deserves taxpayer money, and that new priorities can justify ending support for projects that no longer fit them.
The government also argued that canceling the grants did not silence anyone, because the researchers remain free to seek private money for their work. It warned that letting the appeals court ruling stand would send taxpayer dollars to research that promotes DEI.
What The Researchers Say Comes Next
The researchers’ lawyers told the Court that no court has ever allowed the government to end grants won in a merit-based contest because of the views the research was seen to hold. They called the cuts “a quintessential First Amendment violation.”
Claudia Polsky, a lawyer for the researchers, said the outcome should help similar cases across the country. Lower courts are “not technically bound by anything,” she said, “But I think they will find it quite persuasive.” She said she doubted the White House would try another appeal, since no justice dissented.
The fight is bigger than this one case. University of California lawyers said the administration cut more than $324 million in grants across the system from January to June 2025. A separate court hearing was set for Tuesday, November 17, on whether cuts to Department of Energy grants were also illegal, according to reports.
Sources:
cbsnews.com, latimes.com, laist.com, law.justia.com, cleveland.com



