Biden Judge BLOCKS Trump, Then ACCUSES His Team

Judge's gavel striking sound block on courtroom desk
Photo: nampix / Shutterstock

A federal judge stopped the Trump administration from shutting East Potomac Park and its public golf course one day before the gates were set to close for President Trump’s planned championship rebuild.

Story Snapshot

  • U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes, a Biden appointee, ordered the park and golf course to stay open to the public through November 28 unless the court rules again.
  • The park was set to close on Sunday, November 15, for about 15 months so the course could be rebuilt as a championship course designed by Tom Fazio.
  • The judge found the government’s safety and staffing reasons were likely a cover for pushing the rebuild ahead.
  • Trump called the ruling a “highly destructive and political decision” and said the Interior Department will appeal; a day earlier he promised D.C.-area golfers a 50% discount.

The Order That Kept the Gates Open

On Saturday, November 14, U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes, a Biden appointee who sits on the federal court in Washington, D.C., blocked the Interior Department and the National Park Service from closing East Potomac Park and its golf course. The park was scheduled to close indefinitely the next day. The closure was meant to clear the way for President Trump’s plan to turn the century-old public course into a championship course that could host major events such as the U.S. Open. On Sunday, November 15, Trump called the order a “highly destructive and political decision” and said the government would appeal.

The judge issued a temporary restraining order, a short-term court order that freezes things in place while a case goes on. It keeps the golf course, the rest of the park south of Buckeye Drive SW and Ohio Drive SW open through November 28. The order does not force the government to run golf on the course or to sign a new operator. But the government cannot use the lack of golf as a reason to keep the public out. Areas with active seawall repairs, or an immediate safety threat, can still be closed off.

What the Rebuild Was

East Potomac Park sits on a strip of land along the Potomac River, a short distance from the National Mall. The site has three golf courses with 36 holes in all, a miniature golf course, and a paved loop used by runners and cyclists. The plan would replace that with a single 18-hole championship course designed by Tom Fazio, a well-known golf course architect. Trump announced in October that the work would start November 15 and that the park would be closed for about 15 months.

More than 400 trees had already been cut down at the site before the court stepped in. In October, Reyes found that the tree removal was part of the larger plan to replace the historic course, and she barred more cutting except for imminent safety risks.

Why the Judge Stopped the Closure

The government said it had to close the park because of a crumbling seawall, a wall that holds back the river, along with worn buildings and walkways. It also said no one would be left to run the course, because National Links Trust, the nonprofit that had operated it, would stop after November 15. At a hearing on Friday, November 13, a government lawyer agreed that the administration was carrying out the president’s directive, saying “that’s the way the government works.”

Reyes did not accept those reasons. She called them “pretextual,” meaning a cover story for the real goal of advancing the redesign. She noted that the Park Service had flagged the seawall as early as 2019 without ever closing the whole park. She also pointed out that the government let the Marine Corps Marathon, with more than 30,000 runners, use the area days before it announced the closure. And she said that blaming the lack of an operator “reverses cause and effect,” since the Park Service itself ended the operator’s contract.

The judge wrote that the government “proposes to close a historic park, daily enjoyed by Washingtonians of all stripes, indefinitely.” She said the government likely broke at least two federal laws “to meet an arbitrary deadline.”

The Environmental Law Fight

The case was brought by the DC Preservation League, a historic preservation group, and two local golfers. The judge found they were likely to win on claims under the National Environmental Policy Act, a law that requires agencies to study how a project affects the land, water and historic sites before it starts. She said officials likely broke the project into smaller pieces so its combined effects would never be reviewed as a whole.

She also found that the Park Service likely skipped a required public comment period and did not weigh less drastic steps than a full closure. The Park Service has said its own reviews found the closure needed no full environmental study and would not harm historic property. Agencies close parts of national parks for events and repairs many times a year, and courts have upheld many of those closures. The judge said this closure looked more like a major transformation of the park.

Trump’s Response

On Sunday, Trump hit back on Truth Social. He called the order a “highly destructive and political decision of the judge” and said the Interior Department “will immediately appeal, on an expedited basis.” He warned, “Time is of the essence, or golf seasons, jobs, prestige, and much money, will be lost!” He added, “They don’t call it Trash Island for no reason!”

Trump had also posted on Saturday afternoon, before the judge ruled. He wrote that “Trash Island is currently the Worst Golf Course anywhere in the World.” He said, “Unfortunately, Judge Ana Reyes doesn’t want us to quickly and inexpensively fix up the Course which is, also, very dangerous,” adding that “the Fairways are far too close together.”

He also promised that “anyone living in the D.C. area will be given a 50% discount on any and all Rates charged.” He did not say when the discount would start or which rates it would cover. The groups suing argue the new course would change the character of the public course and make it unaffordable, which Trump denies. The order holds until November 28 unless the court acts sooner or an appeals court steps in.

Sources:

cbsnews.com, bbc.com, newsweek.com, edition.cnn.com, news.bloomberglaw.com, local12.com, krcrtv.com, washingtonpost.com, upi.com