Governor Hochul Takes Strong Stand Against Controversial Energy Practice

New York Governor Kathy Hochul stands firm against fracking, even as Vice President Kamala Harris expresses support for the controversial practice.

At a Glance

Gov. Hochul reaffirms New York’s ban on fracking, emphasizing a commitment to clean energy
VP Harris reverses stance, now supporting fracking, particularly in battleground states
Fracking ban in New York continues despite potential economic benefits
Debate intensifies over environmental concerns versus economic opportunities

Hochul’s Unwavering Opposition to Fracking

New York Governor Kathy Hochul has doubled down on her opposition to fracking in the state, maintaining a firm stance against the controversial practice despite recent support from federal officials. Hochul’s position underscores New York’s commitment to sustainable energy and environmental preservation, even as the debate over fracking’s economic benefits intensifies.

“We’re not fracking, we’re not burning coal. We’re not going backwards,” Hochul stated emphatically, reaffirming New York’s dedication to clean energy alternatives.

https://nypost.com/2024/09/05/us-news/ny-gov-kathy-hochul-doubles-down-on-opposition-to-fracking-even-after-kamala-harris-said-she-backs-it/

Federal Support vs. State Opposition

The governor’s stance comes in stark contrast to recent statements by Vice President Kamala Harris, who expressed support for fracking during a recent event. Harris, reversing her 2020 presidential campaign position, stated, “As vice president I did not ban fracking. As president I will not ban fracking.” This shift in federal perspective highlights the complex political landscape surrounding energy policy, particularly in key battleground states like Pennsylvania where fracking is a significant industry.

“As vice president I did not ban fracking. As president I will not ban fracking,” – Vice President Kamala Harris – Source

Despite the potential economic benefits, Hochul remains steadfast in her opposition to fracking in New York, particularly in the Marcellus Shale formation. The governor’s focus instead lies on promoting carbon-free energy sources such as offshore wind, solar, and geothermal power, aligning with the state’s broader environmental goals.

Economic Implications and Debate

The fracking debate in New York is not merely about environmental concerns; it also encompasses significant economic considerations. A Manhattan Institute report estimated substantial job creation and economic benefits if fracking were allowed in the state. In neighboring Pennsylvania, natural gas fracking is a $41 billion industry supporting 123,000 jobs.

“Natural gas fracking is an estimated $41 billion industry in Pennsylvania — and could be a boon to upstate New York, Howard Husock writes.

“Counties with high fracking potential experience a natural resources boom,” the report found, including $400 million in gas and oil annually and increases of up to 6.1% in total income, 5.5% in employment, and 11% in salaries. Local government coffers swell by 15.5%.” – Source

However, the economic argument has not swayed New York’s leadership. The state’s fracking ban, initiated by former Governor Andrew Cuomo in 2014 due to public health concerns, remains in place. The Democratic-controlled legislature shows little interest in revisiting the issue, despite the potential for economic revitalization in upstate New York, which has experienced significant population loss and economic stagnation.

Environmental Concerns and Future Outlook

Environmental groups, celebrities, and industries such as New York’s wine sector have long opposed fracking, citing concerns over water contamination and other ecological impacts. These worries continue to influence state policy, even as technological advancements in fracking methods emerge.

Recent legislative efforts have sought to expand New York’s fracking ban to include new technologies, such as using liquid carbon dioxide instead of water. This proactive approach aims to prevent potential loopholes that could allow fracking to return to the state under different guises.

As the debate continues, New York’s stance on fracking remains a pivotal issue in the broader conversation about energy policy, environmental protection, and economic development. Governor Hochul’s unwavering opposition to fracking, despite potential economic benefits and shifting federal perspectives, underscores the complex balancing act between environmental stewardship and economic growth that many states face in the evolving landscape of American energy policy.